Internet weighs in on Thew Forrester setback
flockwoodJim Naughton of the Diocese of Washington has an interesting post about the apparent failure of Bishop-elect Kevin G. Thew Forrester to gain consent. The comments are also worth reading. They point out that the coalition opposing Thew Forrester disagree about a lot things, but they shared a commitment to guarding the discipline, faith and worship of the church as articulated in the Book of Common Prayer.
Bryan Owen of Creedal Christian also has a thoughtworthy piece on what this vote “means.”
Among other things, he says:
“Many have noted the way in which this case has united Episcopalians across the theological spectrum. Given the depths of division on so many other issues, I consider that a hopeful sign that there remains a background of agreement behind our disagreements. I pray that we will continue to find ways to build on that background of agreement, and not just in cases like this in which we are united in what we oppose.
But I’m not naïve enough to think that everything is hunky-dory. For the agendas espoused by the far-left and the far-right on the theological spectrum continue to advocate for departures from the generous orthodoxy espoused by the mainstream of the Anglican tradition. The Forrester case is, indeed, a wake-up call that the Episcopal Church has been infiltrated by both bad and heretical theology. It may not be as pervasive as the more stringent doomsayers cry, but it’s there and, left unchecked, will spread and come to seem more and more ‘normal.’ It’s up to the ‘diverse center’ of the Episcopal Church to remain vigilant and to have the courage to say ‘no’ to those agendas.”
June 5th, 2009 at 1:38 pm
Frank is right that the comments to these posts are quite interesting, particularly the ones telling conservative theologues not to start gloating quite yet; Bro. Genpo’s failure to secure the requisite number of votes was not because of his theological ideas, but was because he had, without proper authorization, changed the liturgy in the Book of Common Prayer. Many moderates and liberals apparently saw this as the manner in which Bro. Genpo stepped over the line, not his attempt to merge some of the best parts of Christianity and Buddhism.